In 19th century Britain, 'the truck system' was a relatively common method of exploiting a labour force (despite numerous attempts by Parliament to legislate against it). The system involved the payment of all or part of workers' wages in tokens, scripts, vouchers, etc. that could only be redeemed at specified retail outlets. In many cases, the quality of the merchandise offered in those outlets would be relatively poor and / or the prices would be significantly inflated.

For example, on 3 August 1844, the Kendal Mercury reported that:

A turn-out took place among the numerous labourers engaged at Shap, upon the new line of railway intended to run from Lancaster to Carlisle, in consequence of the establishment of the Truck system in paying the men. The "Tommy shop" of the Contractors was opened in a barn, near the King's Arms Inn; and Wednesday being the day for the first weekly payment of the workmen, they assembled in a multitude to receive their wages. Instead of cash, however, tickets for provisions were tendered, each article being charged at the most extortionate prices. ... The men naturally remonstrated against such gross imposition, but on demanding cash were told they must take what was offered, or go about their business. The consequence has been, that nearly half the hands have quitted the place, and gone off to Wigton in search employment there.

On page 144 of the 1888 version of his book "Our Iron Roads: Their History, Construction, and Administration", F.S. Williams provides us with an insight into why some railway contractors might be tempted to use the truck system, along with some of the unwelcome potential consequences for the railway company:

Mr. Chadwick has stated that the contracts for the execution of railway works were often undertaken at prices which the engineer, if he was a competent man, knew could not pay the contractors. "I have been informed," said he, of one piece of work undertaken by a few contractors, who will lose by the work itself, but who will make upwards of £7,000 by the truck[*] of beer and inferior provisions to the workmen. Here the interests of the contractors in the sale of beer were greater than in the good execution of the work, and men under their arrangements were often at work in a state of intoxication."

[*] Sold under what is called the "truck" system, at a "tally" or beer and provision shop owned by the contractor or his " sub."

We've recently been asked if this form of exploitation occurred during the construction of the Settle & Carlisle Railway (S&CR) and the short answer is "probably not". We've not been able to find any contemporary accounts, tokens or other physical evidence to suggest that the truck system was used along the route of the S&CR. However, we have found several contemporary accounts that expressly state the contrary, including the following from the Bradford Observer on 20 June 1872:

Provision stores are also stationed in all the chief hut villages, where the men can purchase what provisions they may require; but there is not the smallest approach to "truck:" they are paid their wages in coin of the realm, and can go where they like for their goods.

The relevant contemporary account extracts have been transcribed in full below:

Kendal Mercury, Saturday, 3 August 1844

Railway via Kendal. - The Truck System. - A turn-out took place among the numerous labourers engaged at Shap, upon the new line of railway intended to run from Lancaster to Carlisle, in consequence of the establishment of the Truck system in paying the men. The "Tommy shop" of the Contractors was opened in a barn, near the King's Arms Inn; and Wednesday being the day for the first weekly payment of the workmen, they assembled in a multitude to receive their wages. Instead of cash, however, tickets for provisions were tendered, each article being charged at the most extortionate prices. A judgment of the whole may be formed from the following items:
Cheese, sold in Kendal and throughout the district, of better quality than that of the truck shop, at from 5d to 6d per lb, has been charged 8d, (the specimen sent to us is exceedingly rancid.)
Green bacon, worth 5d. sold at 8d.
Bread, sold here at 8d, charged 1s per 4lbs loaf, or 4s per stone!
Tobacco, in Kendal 3d per oz, 1½d per half oz, sold by the railway contractors at 3½d per oz, 2d the half oz.
- The men naturally remonstrated against such gross imposition, but on demanding cash were told they must take what was offered, or go about their business. The consequence has been, that nearly half the hands have quitted the place, and gone off to Wigton in search employment there. We are glad to see that the men have resisted the gross injustice sought to be practised upon them and hope that some of them, for their own sakes, for that of their fellow labourers, and for the benefit of the fair-dealing shopkeepers of the counties of Westmorland and Cumberland, will not pause in mere resentment at the misconduct of the contractors, but will at once proceed to lay informations before the magistrates, in order that the Trucksters may be subjected to the penalties of the law. Their acts are as illegal as they are clearly iniquitous; and ought to be promptly met and put an end to. On other lines several heavy fines have been imposed upon cheating contractors. We trust that the same spirit will be exhibited in this county, in order that the labourers may not be defrauded of their honest earnings.

Bradford Observer, Thursday 20 June 1872

Batty Green is the head-quarters of those who are superintending the construction of the upper portion of contract Number One. This contract, as I have already mentioned, is being carried out by the Midland Company, whose chief agent resides in Settle, and has, besides the general superintendence of the entire section, the special charge of the first nine or ten miles. Mr. W. H. Ashwell has charge of the second division, about seven miles and a quarter; and here, at Batty Green, are his offices. ... Provision stores are also stationed in all the chief hut villages, where the men can purchase what provisions they may require; but there is not the smallest approach to "truck:" they are paid their wages in coin of the realm, and can go where they like for their goods.

Daily News (London), Tuesday 29 October 1872

AMONG THE NAVVIES.
(FROM OUR SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT)
GEARSTONES INN, WEST RIDING OF YORKSHIRE.
...
These men heap fuel lustily into the furnace of their vital energy. Many of them eat eighteen pounds of beef in the week. Beef is their fare. Mutton they reckon of little account, and bacon is only used to' fill up the interstices. As we look at them the "tommy truck" makes its appearance behind an engine. It is a peak-roofed structure, like the cabins shepherds sleep in on the Downs, and it is full to the eaves of great sides of beef that have been sent up from Settle. A firm in Batty Wife-hole supply nearly the whole of the edibles to the navvy communities along this section, sending carts daily or bi-weekly across the moors to the different villages. There is no truck direct and hardly any inferential truck. I make no doubt any other tradesman, if he found it worth his while, might oppose the Batty Wife-hole "tommy-shop."

Herapath's Railway Journal, Saturday 25 January 1873

The Works on the Settle and Carlisle Railway.
New Contracts.
One of the most important contracts on this line of railway, which is now in course of construction for the Midland Company, has just been entered into by Mr. John Bayliss, who is well known as having for some years past been connected with several heavy contracts of a similar character. The contract in question, which embraces the length between Carlisle and the neighbourhood of Penrith, is about 16 miles in length, and passes through several small villages and hamlets in Cumberland. ... With the view of the workmen being supplied with provisions on reasonable terms, the contractor has also established throughout the contract provision stores, at which the men can obtain, if they feel so disposed, good and cheap provisions and clothing, but all payments to the men are made in cash, and there is no obstacle to their obtaining provisions and other articles wherever they can do so. The stores provided by the contractor are solely for the convenience of the men themselves in a comparatively uninhabited district.

Acknowledgements

The contemporary accounts were identified and transcribed by Mark R. Harvey from digitised versions of newspapers accessed via the British Newspaper Archive (https://www.britishnewspaperarchive.co.uk/).